We earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. This never influences our rankings.
Roundup • Water Efficiency

Best Two Button Flush Toilets: Dual Mode Water Saver

Eight rigorously researched picks that deliver a full or reduced flush at the press of a button, backed by EPA WaterSense data, MaP test scores, and thousands of verified owner reviews.

Why Trust Best Flushing Toilets

Research updated June 2026.

Quick Answer

The TOTO Aquia IV is the best two-button flush toilet overall: its 1.0/0.8 GPF dual-flush system earns EPA WaterSense certification, achieves a 1,000-gram MaP score in single-flush mode, and ships with TOTO's CeFiONtect glaze for near-zero residue buildup. For pure value, the Woodbridge T-0001 delivers comparable water savings at a significantly lower retail position.

What Is a Two-Button Flush Toilet?

A two-button flush toilet uses a dual-flush mechanism mounted on the top of the tank or cistern. Pressing the smaller button releases a partial flush (typically 0.8 to 1.0 GPF) for liquid waste, while pressing the larger button delivers a full flush (1.28 to 1.6 GPF) for solid waste. The design lets every household member pick the right flush volume automatically, cutting annual water consumption by 20 to 40 percent compared with a standard 1.6 GPF single-flush toilet.

Two-button flush toilets are sometimes called dual-flush toilets, push-button toilets, or top-flush toilets. The button mechanism replaces the traditional lever handle and connects to a flush valve cartridge inside the tank. When you press the half-flush button, a rubber seal lifts partway and then reseats itself after a set volume exits the tank. When you press the full-flush button, the seal lifts completely until the tank empties.

Most models on sale today pair the two-button actuator with a 2-inch or 3-inch tower-style flush valve rather than the older flapper design. Tower valves have fewer moving parts and tend to outlast flappers by years. They also eliminate the ghost-flushing problem that plagues worn flappers. If you want to understand more about different mechanisms, our overview of best flushing toilets covers all flush systems in depth.

Expert Take

According to published EPA data, a family of four that replaces a 3.5 GPF pre-1994 toilet with a WaterSense-certified dual-flush toilet can save more than 13,000 gallons per year. Even upgrading from a mid-2000s 1.6 GPF single-flush saves roughly 4,000 to 6,000 gallons annually depending on household habits and flush frequency.

The 8 Best Two-Button Flush Toilets Ranked

#1
Best Overall

TOTO Aquia IV Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet

4.7 Best for: most households wanting maximum water savings with zero clog anxiety

The Aquia IV is TOTO's flagship dual-flush two-piece, and its combination of certified efficiency, strong full-flush performance, and CeFiONtect ionic barrier glaze makes it the most consistently recommended two-button toilet across plumbing forums, consumer review aggregators, and independent flush-test databases.

Flush Volumes1.0 / 0.8 GPF
MaP Score1,000 g (full flush)
WaterSenseYes
Bowl ShapeElongated
Trapway2-1/8 in fully glazed
Pros
  • MaP perfect score of 1,000 grams at 1.0 GPF
  • CeFiONtect glaze resists staining and buildup
  • EPA WaterSense certified
  • Slim skirted tank profile
  • TOTO's well-documented 1-year warranty
Cons
  • Higher purchase cost than value-tier competitors
  • Two-piece design means a tank-bowl seam to clean
  • Some owners note the tank button can feel stiff in cold climates

The Aquia IV uses a TOTO WASHLET+ ready design so you can add a compatible bidet seat later without exposed hoses. Owner reviews on major retailers consistently rate flushing reliability at 4.7 or higher, with the most frequent praise directed at the complete absence of double-flushing events even with solid waste.

The 0.8 GPF half-flush is genuinely effective for liquid-only loads, which is where most dual-flush toilets disappoint. The combination of a well-engineered tower valve and a steep bowl angle means even partial-volume flushes clear the bowl cleanly. Maintenance is limited to occasional tower valve cartridge checks; no flapper to replace.

Expert Take

The Aquia IV's MaP perfect score at only 1.0 GPF is the key differentiator. Most toilets that earn a 1,000-gram MaP rating need 1.28 or 1.6 GPF to get there. TOTO achieves it at 1.0 GPF through a combination of bowl geometry, fully glazed trapway, and a well-calibrated flush valve, not just raw water volume.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Aquia IV is the top two-button flush toilet for households that want maximum water savings, proven clog resistance, and a name-brand warranty they can rely on.
#2
Best Value

Woodbridge T-0001 Dual-Flush One-Piece Toilet

4.4 Best for: budget-conscious buyers who want a sleek one-piece look with genuine dual-flush savings

The Woodbridge T-0001 consistently earns praise as the best sub-premium two-button toilet: a fully skirted one-piece profile, 1.0/1.6 GPF dual-flush, and a soft-close seat bundled in the box make it exceptional value relative to its purchase cost.

Flush Volumes1.0 / 1.6 GPF
MaP Score800 g (published)
WaterSenseYes (averaged GPF)
Bowl ShapeElongated
Seat IncludedYes, soft-close
Pros
  • One-piece design with no exposed tank-bowl seam
  • Soft-close seat included at no extra cost
  • Skirted trapway is easy to wipe clean
  • EPA WaterSense qualified
Cons
  • Full flush at 1.6 GPF is higher than ultra-efficient rivals
  • MaP score of 800 g is good but not exceptional
  • Replacement parts availability is narrower than TOTO or Kohler

Owner reviews note the T-0001's ceramic is heavier than expected for the price tier, and the tower flush valve has proven durable across three-plus years of reported use in high-frequency households. The skirted exterior means cleaning is reduced to a quick wipe rather than navigating an exposed trapway.

The 1.0 GPF half-flush handles most liquid-waste loads without streaking. A subset of owners reports the occasional half-flush residue streak on the rear of the bowl, suggesting a slight bowl geometry limitation compared with TOTO, but it is infrequent and addressed by the 1.6 GPF full button on demand. For related options in this style, see our best dual flush toilets guide.

Expert Take

The Woodbridge T-0001 overdelivers on aesthetics and included accessories for its price tier. Its skirted one-piece form typically costs considerably more from heritage brands, making it a strong pick for remodelers working to a budget but wanting a modern bathroom profile.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Woodbridge T-0001 is the smartest value play in the two-button flush category, blending a modern one-piece profile with genuine WaterSense efficiency and a bundled soft-close seat.
#3
Best Compact

American Standard H2Option Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet

4.3 Best for: smaller bathrooms needing a right-height elongated bowl with dual-flush savings

American Standard's H2Option brings the brand's proven VorMax-derived trapway engineering to a dual-flush package with a 1.0/0.5 GPF split that is among the most aggressive water-saving configurations sold in the U.S. residential market.

Flush Volumes1.0 / 0.5 GPF
MaP Score1,000 g (full flush)
WaterSenseYes
Bowl ShapeElongated, right-height
Trapway2-3/8 in fully glazed
Pros
  • 0.5 GPF half-flush is the lowest on this list
  • MaP score of 1,000 g at 1.0 GPF full flush
  • EverClean surface inhibits stain and odor bacteria
  • Wide parts availability nationwide
Cons
  • 0.5 GPF half-flush can occasionally leave residue in mineral-heavy water areas
  • Standard seat not included
  • Lever-style actuator on some SKUs rather than push button

American Standard's EverClean surface treatment is a real differentiator: independent lab tests show it suppresses bacteria growth on the vitreous china surface for the life of the toilet, reducing both cleaning frequency and odor between deep cleans. The trapway at 2-3/8 inches is among the widest in this category.

The H2Option's 0.5 GPF partial flush is impressive on paper but requires reasonable water pressure to be fully effective. Homes with supply pressure below 20 PSI may occasionally see a second half-flush needed. In households with normal city pressure, the partial flush clears liquid waste completely. Compare this option with our best American Standard toilets roundup for more context.

Expert Take

The H2Option's 0.5/1.0 GPF combination delivers the best theoretical annual water savings on this list. A household averaging 5 flushes per day per person, split 70/30 liquid-to-solid, would use approximately 1.1 GPF average -- significantly below any single-flush 1.28 GPF model on the market.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The American Standard H2Option's ultra-low 0.5 GPF partial flush earns it the title of most water-efficient push-button toilet on the U.S. market, provided your home has adequate supply pressure.
#4
Best One-Piece Premium

TOTO Drake II Two-Piece Elongated Dual-Flush Toilet

4.5 Best for: TOTO loyalists who prefer a traditional two-piece profile with dual-flush capability

The Drake II is TOTO's heritage workhorse, and the dual-flush variant pairs the same proven TORNADO FLUSH bowl technology with a 1.28/0.9 GPF dual-flush actuator, landing it in the EPA WaterSense bracket while retaining the Drake line's legendary clog-free reputation.

Flush Volumes1.28 / 0.9 GPF
MaP Score1,000 g (full flush)
WaterSenseYes
Bowl ShapeElongated
Flush TechTOTO TORNADO FLUSH
Pros
  • TORNADO FLUSH creates a cyclonic rinse with no rim holes to clog
  • CeFiONtect surface glaze standard
  • Best-in-class parts availability for the Drake platform
  • Proven 20-plus year Drake platform reliability
Cons
  • Full flush at 1.28 GPF uses slightly more water than Aquia IV's 1.0 GPF
  • Two-piece adds a cleaning seam
  • Premium price over Woodbridge or Swiss Madison competitors

The Drake II's rimless bowl design is a genuine maintenance advantage: traditional rim jets accumulate mineral scale over time and gradually reduce flush power. TOTO's rimless approach uses two angled nozzles at the back of the bowl to create a swirling water pattern that covers the full bowl interior without any jets to descale.

Owner satisfaction with the Drake II dual flush is consistently high, though a small subset of reviews mention the 0.9 GPF partial flush occasionally requires a second press when there is significant paper. This is a known trait of the slightly lower partial-flush volume -- the Aquia IV at 0.8 GPF handles it better due to bowl geometry differences. For more context on this model family, see our TOTO Drake series guide.

Expert Take

The Drake II dual-flush may be the single most future-proof toilet purchase in this roundup. The Drake platform has been in continuous production for over two decades, meaning replacement tower valves, fill valves, seats, and actuator buttons are stocked at virtually every plumbing supplier in North America.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Drake II dual-flush is the smart long-term investment for homeowners who value parts availability and a proven platform over cutting-edge efficiency numbers.
#5
Best Wall-Mount Style

Swiss Madison St. Tropez Dual-Flush One-Piece Toilet

4.2 Best for: modern minimalist bathroom designs where clean lines matter as much as flush performance

Swiss Madison's St. Tropez brings a distinctly European-inspired skirted profile and chrome push-button actuator to an accessible price point, with a 1.1/1.6 GPF dual-flush system and a fully skirted trapway that wipes clean in seconds.

Flush Volumes1.1 / 1.6 GPF
WaterSenseQualified
Bowl ShapeElongated
SeatSoft-close included
FinishGlossy white ceramic
Pros
  • Fully skirted profile is among the cleanest aesthetics at this price
  • Soft-close seat included in box
  • Chrome dual-flush actuator looks premium
  • Compact overall footprint suits powder rooms
Cons
  • Full flush at 1.6 GPF is the least efficient option on this list
  • MaP score not independently published; manufacturer-stated 800 g
  • Parts sourcing more limited than TOTO/Kohler/American Standard

The St. Tropez consistently earns strong reviews from buyers prioritizing aesthetics. Verified owner feedback highlights the solid chrome actuator button and the absence of any visible trapway as the top reasons for purchase satisfaction. Flush performance for day-to-day use is described as reliable and quiet.

Swiss Madison toilets are generally distributed through online retail and some home improvement chains. The limited parts network is the main trade-off versus heritage brands, but the tower flush valve in the St. Tropez is a standard metric-thread cartridge style compatible with aftermarket suppliers. For a broader category view, our Swiss Madison toilets guide covers all current models.

Expert Take

Swiss Madison has carved out a real niche by delivering a European spa-inspired aesthetic at a third of the cost of comparable models from Duravit or Villeroy and Boch. The St. Tropez is the entry point: if the design language appeals, the flush performance is sufficient for most households even if it does not top the MaP charts.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The St. Tropez is the best-looking two-button toilet on this list at a mid-range purchase cost, making it the pick for design-led bathroom remodels where aesthetics lead the decision.
#6
Best for Septic Systems

Gerber Avalanche Dual-Flush Two-Piece Toilet

4.1 Best for: rural homes on septic systems where reducing water load on the tank is a priority

Gerber's Avalanche dual-flush brings the brand's reliable porcelain quality and 2-3/8-inch fully glazed trapway to a 0.8/1.28 GPF configuration, making it a dependable pick for septic households that want strong full-flush performance without excessive tank loading.

Flush Volumes0.8 / 1.28 GPF
Trapway2-3/8 in fully glazed
WaterSenseYes
Bowl ShapeElongated or round available
WarrantyLimited lifetime on china
Pros
  • Wide 2-3/8 in trapway reduces clog risk
  • Both elongated and round bowl options available
  • Lifetime limited warranty on the vitreous china
  • Available through plumbing supply houses, not just online
Cons
  • MaP score not independently verified in public database
  • Less visible brand presence in big-box retail
  • Push-button actuator button is plastic with a less premium feel

Gerber is less familiar to many homeowners than TOTO or Kohler, but the brand is a preferred specification among commercial plumbing contractors in the Mid-Atlantic and Southeast U.S. Its lifetime limited china warranty is a genuine differentiator: if the vitreous china cracks from a manufacturing defect, Gerber replaces it at no cost.

The Avalanche's 1.28 GPF full flush and wide trapway combination makes it resistant to clogging even in households with large-family usage. The 0.8 GPF partial flush reduces septic system water loading meaningfully over daily use. For full Gerber brand context, see our best Gerber toilets overview.

Expert Take

For homeowners on private septic systems, every gallon per flush matters more than in sewer-connected homes because an overloaded septic tank can back up or require early pump-out. The Avalanche's 0.8/1.28 GPF split, combined with a large trapway that rarely needs a second flush, is an optimal trade-off for this situation.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Gerber Avalanche is the sensible, contractor-approved two-button flush toilet for households on septic, prioritizing trapway width and long-term durability over design flair.
#7
Best Comfort Height

Kohler Cimarron Comfort Height Dual-Flush Toilet

4.4 Best for: taller users and households with seniors who need chair-height seating comfort

Kohler's Cimarron Comfort Height dual-flush uses a 1.28/0.8 GPF actuator paired with the Cimarron's class-five flushing technology and a bowl height of 16.5 inches from the floor to the rim, putting it at wheelchair-accessible ADA height with full dual-flush efficiency.

Flush Volumes1.28 / 0.8 GPF
Bowl Height16.5 in (comfort height)
WaterSenseYes
Bowl ShapeElongated
Flush TechClass Five
Pros
  • ADA-compliant comfort height aids seniors and taller users
  • Class Five flushing technology rated to move 1,000 g per flush
  • Kohler's extensive nationwide dealer and parts network
  • Available in multiple colors beyond white/biscuit
Cons
  • Dual-flush SKUs are a subset of the Cimarron line; confirm model number before ordering
  • Some owners report the dual-flush button module needs occasional adjustment
  • Not the lowest-cost option in this category

The Kohler Cimarron has one of the largest installed bases of any toilet in North America, which translates to abundant owner data. Aggregated reviews on major retail platforms rate the dual-flush Cimarron above 4.4 stars across thousands of reviews, with seat comfort and flushing reliability as the two most cited positives.

Kohler's Class Five flush technology channels water into the bowl through a larger, faster rush rather than a sustained flow, achieving effective bulk removal at 1.28 GPF without needing a pressure-assist mechanism. The 0.8 GPF partial flush adequately handles liquid waste in the majority of owner-reported use cases.

Expert Take

For households where an aging-in-place strategy is part of the remodel plan, choosing the Cimarron Comfort Height dual-flush now eliminates a future toilet swap. The dual-flush feature simultaneously addresses accessibility and water efficiency, making this a practical specification for master bathrooms in homes occupied by adults over 55.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Kohler Cimarron Comfort Height dual-flush is the best two-button toilet for taller adults and aging-in-place remodels, combining ADA height, strong Class Five flushing, and Kohler's industry-leading parts network.
#8
Best Round Bowl

American Standard Champion 4 Dual-Flush Elongated Two-Piece

4.2 Best for: households that have experienced chronic clogging and want proven bulk-waste clearance with dual-flush efficiency

American Standard's Champion 4 platform is the brand's most clog-resistant line, and the dual-flush variant adds a 1.0/1.6 GPF push-button actuator to the Champion 4's famously large 4-inch flush valve and 2-3/8-inch trapway, making it the most aggressive clog-fighting two-button toilet available.

Flush Volumes1.0 / 1.6 GPF
Flush Valve4-inch (largest in category)
Trapway2-3/8 in fully glazed
MaP Score1,000 g
WaterSenseAveraged GPF qualifies
Pros
  • 4-inch flush valve delivers the most powerful gravity flush available
  • 2-3/8 in trapway eliminates virtually all clogging scenarios
  • MaP 1,000 g score
  • American Standard's nationwide warranty service network
Cons
  • Full flush at 1.6 GPF uses more water than lower-volume competitors
  • Tank is taller and bulkier than modern skirted designs
  • More traditional aesthetic than Swiss Madison or Woodbridge

The Champion 4's 4-inch flush valve is the core specification that sets it apart. Standard toilets use a 2-inch or 3-inch flush valve; the Champion 4's oversized valve releases water faster into the bowl, creating a surge that overcomes resistance that would stop a standard-speed flush. The dual-flush actuator on this platform controls the same large valve but limits the tank drain volume on the partial press.

This is the best option for households with older pipes in aging homes, heavy family use, or a documented history of clogs. The trade-off is that the 1.6 GPF full flush volume is the least efficient on this list, though the dual-flush mechanism still reduces overall water use when the partial flush is used appropriately for liquid waste.

Expert Take

If your household has had more than one clog in the past year with a standard toilet, the Champion 4 dual-flush is worth the 1.6 GPF full-flush trade-off. Repeated clogging wastes far more water over time (through extended manual plunging, running water, and sometimes emergency service calls) than the marginal difference between 1.28 GPF and 1.6 GPF full-flush volumes.

Check price on Amazon
Bottom Line: The Champion 4 dual-flush is the right choice for clog-prone households: its 4-inch valve and wide trapway eliminate virtually all blockage scenarios while the push-button dual flush still reduces water use versus a single-flush 1.6 GPF toilet.

Quick Comparison: Two-Button Flush Toilets at a Glance

Model Flush Volumes (GPF) WaterSense MaP Score Bowl Shape Rating
TOTO Aquia IV 1.0 / 0.8 Yes 1,000 g Elongated 4.7
Woodbridge T-0001 1.6 / 1.0 Yes 800 g Elongated 4.4
American Standard H2Option 1.0 / 0.5 Yes 1,000 g Elongated 4.3
TOTO Drake II Dual Flush 1.28 / 0.9 Yes 1,000 g Elongated 4.5
Swiss Madison St. Tropez 1.6 / 1.1 Yes 800 g* Elongated 4.2
Gerber Avalanche 1.28 / 0.8 Yes N/A pub. Elongated/Round 4.1
Kohler Cimarron CH 1.28 / 0.8 Yes 1,000 g Elongated 4.4
American Standard Champion 4 1.6 / 1.0 Avg. GPF 1,000 g Elongated 4.2

*Manufacturer-stated; independent MaP score not published for this model. MaP scores sourced from map-testing.com public database.

How Does a Two-Button Flush Mechanism Work Inside the Tank?

A two-button flush mechanism connects to a tower-style flush valve cartridge inside the tank. Pressing the small button lifts a rubber seal partway, releasing a pre-set partial water volume (typically 0.5 to 1.1 GPF) before the seal drops back into place. Pressing the large button lifts the seal fully, allowing the entire tank to drain (1.0 to 1.6 GPF) in a single gravity-powered rush through the trapway and into the drain line.

The dual-flush tower valve differs from a traditional flapper in several key ways. A flapper relies on buoyancy: it floats up when you pull the lever and sinks back when water drops below a threshold, which means flush volume is partly determined by how quickly the tank drains and how fast the flapper reseats. This creates variability in flush volume and is the source of ghost-flushing when flappers wear and no longer seal perfectly.

Tower valves eliminate buoyancy-based timing. The partial button mechanically limits the lift of the seal to a calibrated position, then a spring returns it to closed when you release the button. The full button lifts the seal beyond that calibrated point and holds it up via a different latch until the tank is empty, then gravity drops the seal. The result is consistent, repeatable flush volumes on every use.

Most two-button flush cartridges are interchangeable with standard metric threading and can be replaced as a DIY project without tools in 20 to 30 minutes. Major suppliers including Fluidmaster and Geberit produce aftermarket cartridges compatible with most brand tanks if the original part is discontinued.

Expert Take

The mechanical reliability advantage of tower valves over flappers is significant over a 10- to 15-year toilet lifespan. Flappers typically require replacement every 3 to 5 years as the rubber degrades, especially in areas with chlorinated or high-mineral water. Tower valve cartridges in quality toilets routinely last 10-plus years between service events.

Are Two-Button Flush Toilets Worth It for Water Savings?

Yes, two-button flush toilets are worth it for most households: the EPA estimates that switching from a pre-1994 3.5 GPF toilet to a WaterSense-certified dual-flush model saves a family of four approximately 13,000 gallons per year, while even upgrading from a 2000s-era 1.6 GPF single-flush model saves 4,000 to 6,000 gallons annually depending on flush habits. Many water utilities offer rebates of $50 to $150 per fixture for installing WaterSense-certified dual-flush toilets, which can offset the incremental purchase cost within 1 to 3 years.

The water savings case for dual-flush toilets rests on usage data. Research on actual household behavior consistently shows that approximately 65 to 75 percent of daily toilet uses are liquid-only. If each of those uses draws 0.8 GPF rather than 1.6 GPF, the accumulated saving across a household of four averaging 8 total flushes per day is substantial:

Single-flush at 1.6 GPF: 8 flushes x 1.6 = 12.8 gallons per day, 4,672 gallons per year.
Dual-flush (70% partial at 0.8 GPF, 30% full at 1.28 GPF): (5.6 x 0.8) + (2.4 x 1.28) = 4.48 + 3.07 = 7.55 gallons per day, 2,756 gallons per year.
Annual saving: approximately 1,916 gallons per person, or 7,664 gallons for a family of four.

These are conservative figures using a moderate 1.28 GPF full-flush model. The TOTO Aquia IV's 1.0 GPF full flush pushes annual savings higher. In regions with tiered water pricing, this volume reduction can translate to $40 to $120 per year in utility savings depending on local water and sewer rates.

The payback period for the incremental cost between a standard single-flush toilet and a dual-flush model depends on local utility rates and rebate availability. In high-cost water markets such as the California coast, Southwest, and parts of the Northeast, payback periods of 2 to 4 years are common based on utility rebate programs alone. See our best water saving toilets guide for a deeper analysis of water efficiency across all flush types.

What Is the Difference Between Dual Flush and Dual Button Flush Toilets?

Dual flush and dual button flush are terms used interchangeably in most retail and review contexts -- both refer to toilets that offer two flush volumes selectable by the user. "Dual button" specifically describes the actuator type: a two-button push plate mounted on the tank lid, typically with a smaller button for the partial flush and a larger button (or full-plate press) for the full flush. Some dual-flush toilets use a lever with two positions rather than buttons, but the two-button format is the most common in residential models sold today.

The confusion arises because early dual-flush toilets used a variety of actuator formats: side levers with a push/pull motion, trigger handles, or single large buttons that required different press durations. Modern two-button actuators are the evolved standard and are preferred because the intent is unambiguous for all household members including children and guests.

There is also a distinction between dual-flush gravity toilets (the models on this list) and dual-flush pressure-assist systems. Pressure-assist dual flush uses compressed air in a sealed inner tank to drive water through the bowl at higher velocity, which can overcome the reduced volume of a partial flush more effectively in low-pressure homes. However, pressure-assist systems are noisier, more expensive, and the inner pressure vessel requires periodic inspection. For most residential applications, gravity dual-flush with a well-designed tower valve is sufficient and quieter. Our dual flush vs pressure assist comparison covers this in full detail.

How Do You Fix a Two-Button Flush That Keeps Running?

A two-button flush toilet that keeps running after flushing is almost always caused by one of three things: a worn or misaligned tower valve cartridge seal that is not reseating fully, a fill valve that is set too high causing water to spill into the overflow tube, or a debris particle lodged under the cartridge seal preventing a watertight closure. Removing the tank lid, flushing, and watching the mechanism operate visually identifies which component is at fault within a few minutes.

Here is the diagnostic sequence recommended for a running two-button flush toilet:

Step 1: Check the water level. The water in the tank should sit approximately 1 inch below the top of the overflow tube (the tall plastic cylinder in the center of the tank). If water is reaching or overflowing the tube, the fill valve float needs to be adjusted lower. Most fill valves have a thumb screw or a clip on the float arm to lower the cutoff level.

Step 2: Check the tower valve seal. Flush the toilet and watch the cartridge reseat after the tank empties. If it drops crooked or bounces slightly before settling, the tower valve cartridge may need replacement. Cartridge sets for most brands are available for under $20 at plumbing suppliers and install by unscrewing the old cartridge and threading in the new one.

Step 3: Check for debris. With the water off and tank empty, lift the tower valve cartridge (it typically unscrews counterclockwise) and inspect the seat it seals against. Small particles of debris from supply lines, especially in homes with older galvanized pipes, can lodge in the seat and prevent a watertight close. A quick rinse with clean water and a wipe with a cloth resolves this immediately.

Unlike flapper-based toilets, two-button flush mechanisms almost never ghost-flush due to slow rubber degradation, because the seal is a rigid-edged rubber disc rather than a heat-stressed flexible flapper. Running is typically caused by the above three issues rather than gradual material decay.

Which Two-Button Flush Toilet Has the Best MaP Score?

Three two-button flush toilets on this list achieve the maximum MaP score of 1,000 grams at their full-flush volume: the TOTO Aquia IV (at just 1.0 GPF full flush), the American Standard H2Option (at 1.0 GPF full flush), and the TOTO Drake II dual flush (at 1.28 GPF). The TOTO Aquia IV's 1,000-gram score at 1.0 GPF is the most impressive because it achieves maximum clog resistance at the lowest water volume, a combination that no other toilet on this list replicates.

MaP (Maximum Performance) testing is conducted by a third-party organization that measures how many grams of soybean paste and toilet paper a toilet can flush cleanly in a single flush. A score of 600 grams is the minimum for WaterSense certification; 800 grams is considered good; 1,000 grams is the maximum score and indicates the toilet will handle virtually any residential load without clogging.

MaP scores are published at map-testing.com and updated periodically as new models are tested. It is worth checking the database directly when evaluating any toilet not on this list, as manufacturer claims and actual MaP results sometimes differ. Scores are listed by flush volume, model number, and test date.

For two-button flush toilets specifically, the MaP score that matters most is the full-flush score, since partial flushes are used for liquid waste where bulk clearance is not the challenge. The partial flush needs primarily to rinse the bowl clean -- a characteristic driven more by bowl geometry and glaze quality than raw MaP score. Our MaP score guide explains how to read the database and what scores mean for different household situations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What GPF should I look for in a two-button flush toilet?

For the partial flush, 0.8 GPF or lower is ideal for liquid-waste efficiency. For the full flush, 1.0 to 1.28 GPF balances power and water savings and qualifies for EPA WaterSense certification. Models with 1.6 GPF full flush still save water compared with pre-2000 toilets but are less efficient than 1.28 GPF alternatives.

Is a two-button flush toilet harder to maintain than a handle toilet?

No. The tower valve mechanism used in most two-button flush toilets has fewer moving parts than a traditional flapper-and-lever system. Tower valve cartridges are more durable than rubber flappers and do not require the same frequency of replacement. Button actuator modules are also replaceable as a single unit if they become stiff or fail.

Can I convert my existing toilet to a two-button flush?

Yes, in many cases. Retrofit dual-flush conversion kits (Fluidmaster 555CKR and similar) replace the existing flapper and fill valve with a tower valve and push-button actuator that fits through the existing tank lid hole or adds a new top-mount button. These kits work with most standard toilet tanks and are available for under $30. Tanks smaller than 1.6 gallons may not have enough volume to support a meaningful dual-flush split.

Do dual flush toilets require more water pressure than single flush models?

No, gravity dual-flush toilets operate on the same supply pressure requirements as standard gravity-flush toilets: a minimum of 8 to 10 PSI at the supply valve is sufficient. Pressure-assist versions require 20 to 80 PSI but these are a separate product category. If your home has low water pressure, a gravity two-button flush toilet will work fine.

Which button should I press for liquid waste and which for solid?

The universal convention on two-button flush toilets is: small button (or half the dual-button plate) for the partial flush used with liquid waste and light paper use; large button (or the full plate) for the full flush used with solid waste. This is standardized across all brands including TOTO, Kohler, Woodbridge, and American Standard. Some tanks print a small diagram on the actuator plate to confirm.

Are two-button flush toilets EPA WaterSense certified?

Many are, but not all. EPA WaterSense certification for dual-flush toilets requires that the weighted average flush volume (calculated as one full flush to two partial flushes in a standard use pattern) does not exceed 1.28 GPF. Most models from TOTO, Kohler, and American Standard meet this threshold. Always check the specific model's EPA WaterSense listing at epa.gov/watersense before purchasing.

What is the difference between a tower flush valve and a flapper in a dual-flush toilet?

A tower flush valve is a cylindrical cartridge in the center of the tank that rises and falls on a vertical axis. A flapper is a rubber disc on a hinge that swings open and closed. Tower valves are standard in two-button flush toilets because they allow mechanical control over partial flush volume through a calibrated lift position, something flappers cannot achieve reliably. Tower valves also eliminate the buoyancy-dependent timing that causes flapper variability and ghost flushing.

Can I put a toilet seat with a bidet on a two-button flush toilet?

Yes. Two-button flush toilets are standard vitreous china bowls with the same seat bolt hole spacing as single-flush toilets. Any bidet seat compatible with the bowl shape (elongated or round) fits identically. TOTO Aquia IV is specifically designed WASHLET+ compatible, meaning the supply line and seat can be integrated without exposed hoses, but standard bidet seats work on any bowl with a nearby supply valve.

How long do two-button flush actuator mechanisms last?

Quality tower valve cartridges from brands like TOTO, Geberit, and Fluidmaster typically last 8 to 15 years under normal use before the rubber seal shows wear. The push-button actuator plate mechanism itself rarely fails; when it does, the module is designed to unclip and replace as a unit. Budget-tier toilets with lower-quality plastic components may see button stiffness or cracking earlier, typically at 5 to 7 years.

Are dual flush toilets good for households with children?

Yes. Children adapt quickly to two-button flush toilets and the visual size difference between the buttons provides an intuitive cue. Households with young children actually see greater water savings from dual-flush toilets because children tend to over-flush with single-flush models. The main concern is making sure children can reach the tank top to press the button, which is addressed by comfort-height or standard-height selection based on the child's age.

Do water utility rebates apply to two-button flush toilets?

Many do. The EPA WaterSense partner program coordinates with utilities nationwide to offer rebates for installing WaterSense-certified toilets. Rebate amounts vary from $25 to $200 per fixture depending on the utility and local water scarcity conditions. The EPA maintains a searchable rebate finder at epa.gov/watersense. Many California, Arizona, Colorado, and Texas utilities have active rebate programs covering EPA WaterSense dual-flush toilets specifically.

What is the best two-button flush toilet for a rental property?

The Gerber Avalanche dual flush or the Woodbridge T-0001 are the best two-button flush options for rental properties. Both have durable ceramic construction, low maintenance requirements, tower valve mechanisms that resist flapper-style ghost flushing, and WaterSense certification that can reduce utility bills. For properties where the landlord pays water, the Aquia IV's superior efficiency may justify its higher purchase cost through long-term utility savings.

How do I clean a two-button toilet's push actuator?

The push-button actuator plate on most two-button flush toilets lifts off the tank by pressing inward and rotating counterclockwise, or by pressing a small release tab on the underside of the plate. Once removed, it can be wiped clean with a damp cloth and mild bathroom cleaner. Avoid harsh abrasives on chrome-finished buttons to prevent surface dulling. Replace the plate by aligning the tabs and rotating clockwise until it clicks.

Do two-button flush toilets work with septic systems?

Yes, and they are actually recommended for septic systems. Septic tanks require a balance between enough water volume to move solids through the tank and not so much water that the bacteria-to-waste ratio is diluted. Dual-flush toilets reduce total daily water input to the septic system by 20 to 40 percent versus older single-flush models, extending pump-out intervals and reducing tank stress. The full 1.28 GPF flush provides adequate volume to clear the drain line to the tank.

What rough-in distance do most two-button flush toilets require?

The vast majority of two-button flush toilets on the U.S. market are designed for a standard 12-inch rough-in distance (floor drain center to wall). Some models are available in 10-inch or 14-inch rough-in variants for older homes with non-standard plumbing. Always measure your rough-in before purchasing. TOTO, Kohler, and American Standard all offer the same dual-flush models in 10-inch and 14-inch rough-in versions as separate SKUs.

Can a plumber convert a two-button flush toilet back to a single-flush lever?

Yes. The tower valve cartridge in a dual-flush tank can be replaced with a standard flapper-and-lever mechanism if a homeowner or plumber prefers to revert to a handle-operated single flush. The tank itself is identical to a standard gravity-flush tank. This is rarely done since dual-flush tanks perform equally well as single-flush if both buttons are always pressed in full-flush mode, but the conversion is possible if needed for accessibility reasons.

Is one GPF really enough to flush solid waste?

Yes, for toilets designed around a 1.0 GPF full-flush volume. The TOTO Aquia IV and American Standard H2Option both achieve a 1,000-gram MaP score at 1.0 GPF, meaning they pass the maximum third-party bulk clearance test at that volume. The key is bowl geometry and trapway design: a steep bowl angle and a fully glazed 2-inch-plus trapway at the correct size allows 1.0 GPF of water to carry waste through efficiently. Older toilet bowl shapes designed for 3.5 GPF would fail at 1.0 GPF.

What is the average cost to install a two-button flush toilet?

Plumber installation for a toilet replacement averages $150 to $350 for labor in most U.S. markets, with the lower end representing a straightforward same-rough-in swap and the higher end covering complications like wax ring issues, shut-off valve replacement, or supply line work. The two-button flush mechanism does not add any labor complexity over a standard toilet installation; connection and testing are identical. DIY installation with basic tools takes 1 to 2 hours for most homeowners.

Sources

  • EPA WaterSense, epa.gov/watersense
  • MaP flush testing, map-testing.com
  • Manufacturer published specifications

Our Verdict

The TOTO Aquia IV is the best two-button flush toilet overall because it is the only model on this list that achieves a 1,000-gram MaP score at a 1.0 GPF full flush -- meaning it clears the maximum third-party bulk test at the most water-efficient volume. Pair it with the 0.8 GPF partial flush and a household of four can realistically save over 7,000 gallons annually versus a 1.6 GPF single-flush toilet. For buyers who need to watch purchase cost, the Woodbridge T-0001 delivers WaterSense-qualified efficiency, a bundled soft-close seat, and a skirted one-piece profile at a significantly lower outlay. Households prioritizing clog elimination above all else should choose the American Standard Champion 4 dual flush for its 4-inch flush valve and wide trapway. Whatever model you select, any EPA WaterSense-certified two-button flush toilet will reduce water bills, lower septic load, and eliminate flapper-related maintenance compared with a standard handle-flush toilet.

How we rank & our data sources

We do not run physical lab tests. Rankings are built from published, verifiable data and real owner feedback, never paid placement.

Researched by Marcus Bell · Last updated June 28, 2026 · Our review method

M
Researched by Marcus Bell

Marcus compiles bathroom-fixture data, MaP flush scores, GPF ratings, trapway and flush-valve specs, and weighs them against thousands of verified owner reviews to build our rankings. He does not run physical lab tests; every verdict is sourced from published specifications, certifications (MaP, EPA WaterSense) and real owner feedback.

Updated June 2026 · Toilets
Keep reading

Related guides

Best Mission Toilets (2026)

Best Mission Toilets (2026)

Toilets
4.6

Mission-style toilets favor honest, simple lines and strong proportions over ornamentation, pairing naturally with Arts and Crafts bathrooms, and the strongest ones…

Read the guide
Best Victorian Toilets (2026)

Best Victorian Toilets (2026)

Toilets
4.6

Elaborate high-tank pull-chain designs and ornately scalloped silhouettes that bring genuine period drama without sacrificing a modern, reliable flush.

Read the guide
Best French Toilets (2026)

Best French Toilets (2026)

Toilets
4.6

Refined, softly curved one-piece and skirted silhouettes with a polished, Parisian-elegant profile, paired with verified MaP flush scores rather than a stylist's…

Read the guide