
Best French Toilets (2026)
ToiletsRefined, softly curved one-piece and skirted silhouettes with a polished, Parisian-elegant profile, paired with verified MaP flush scores rather than a stylist's…
Read the guideA toilet that rocks, wobbles, or sits at an angle is not just annoying. It can crack the wax ring seal, allow sewer gas into your home, and eventually fracture the porcelain base. This guide walks through every cause, every fix, and exactly how to get a toilet sitting perfectly flat on any floor type.
Research updated June 2026.
A toilet that is not level is most commonly caused by uneven subfloor, a failed or incorrectly installed wax ring, loose toilet flange bolts, or floor tile with uneven grout joints. Plastic toilet shims inserted under the base, then tightened evenly with the toilet bolts, fix most cases in under 30 minutes without removing the toilet.
Floor-mounted toilets tolerate a small amount of floor variation, but once one side of the base lifts noticeably off the floor, the seal between the toilet horn and the wax ring begins to flex with every flush. Over months, that flexing breaks the wax ring, which allows wastewater to seep under the floor and allows sewer gas to enter the room. Fixing a toilet that is not level is a repair that repays itself quickly in both plumbing integrity and daily comfort.
Before reaching for tools, it helps to know whether the toilet is truly out of level (the base is not horizontal) or merely rocking (the base touches the floor at two points but not at a third). Both problems feel similar underfoot, but the fix is slightly different. A spirit level laid across the bowl rim tells you within seconds which situation you are dealing with.
| Cause | Visual Clue | Typical Fix | Difficulty | Average Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Uneven floor or subfloor | Toilet tilts to one side | Toilet shims + caulk | Easy | 20 min |
| Uneven tile or grout ridge | Rock on one corner | Shims or grind grout | Easy | 15 min |
| Loose flange bolts | Wobble, no tilt | Tighten bolts evenly | Easy | 10 min |
| Damaged or settled flange | Tilt + water at base | Flange repair kit | Moderate | 1-2 hrs |
| Warped or rotted subfloor | Soft floor around base | Subfloor repair + reinstall | Advanced | Half day |
| Cracked toilet base | Hairline crack visible | Replace toilet | Moderate | 2-3 hrs |
The six most common causes are: uneven subfloor or floor tiles, a settled or damaged toilet flange, overtightened or loose toilet bolts that pull the base out of plane, a compressed wax ring that has shifted, floor tile grout lines creating a ridge under the base, and in older homes a subfloor that has warped or rotted. Any one of these can prevent the toilet from sitting flat.
Identifying the cause before you buy supplies saves a trip to the hardware store. A spirit level and a firm hand-pressure test on each corner of the base will tell you which corner is high or low and whether the toilet rocks in a diagonal pattern, which points to a floor irregularity rather than a mechanical problem with the toilet itself.
Place a 24-inch spirit level across the bowl rim from left to right, then front to back. A bubble resting outside the center marks means one side is high by a measurable amount. Most small tiles or shimmed floors show variations of 1/8 inch to 3/8 inch, which is enough to break a wax ring over time.
Then press firmly on each rear corner of the toilet base. If the toilet rocks diagonally, the floor underneath is not flat. If it wobbles without rocking, the flange bolts may be loose rather than the floor being uneven. Distinguishing between these two conditions determines whether shims or bolt tightening will solve the problem.
A quick diagnostic sequence takes less than five minutes and avoids spending money on parts you do not need:
Plumbing contractors commonly report that a toilet that "always needed two flushes" turned out to have a partially unsealed wax ring caused by years of rocking on an uneven floor. Restoring the level and replacing the wax ring restored both the seal and normal flush performance. A misaligned toilet is not just a comfort issue. It is a plumbing integrity issue. Fix it before the wax ring fails completely and water damage adds cost to the project.
Purchase a bag of plastic toilet shims (often sold as "toilet shim sets" or "closet shims"). Slide the tapered end of one shim under the low side of the toilet base until the spirit level reads flat. Repeat on any other low points. Once level, score the shim flush with the base using a utility knife, press silicone caulk around the entire base to seal out moisture, and allow it to cure before use.
Never use wooden shims under a toilet base. Wood absorbs moisture from the floor, swells, compresses unevenly, and eventually rots. Plastic or composite shims are the correct material for a permanent result. Most plumbing supply stores sell color-matched sets designed to be invisible once caulked.
This is the correct method when the toilet is out of level but the wax ring appears intact (no water staining, no sewer smell).
Tools and materials needed: spirit level, plastic toilet shims, utility knife, painter's tape, silicone caulk (white or tile-matched), caulk gun, adjustable wrench.
The common mistake is tightening the toilet bolts before the shims are perfectly placed. Once the bolts are tight, the toilet cannot shift. Do all the shimming and leveling work first, then tighten. Also tighten both bolts in small equal increments rather than fully tightening one side before touching the other, which pulls the base out of plane even if the shims are correctly positioned.
You need to remove the toilet when the wax ring has already failed (shown by water staining, soft subfloor, or sewer odor), when the toilet flange is cracked or has dropped below floor level, or when the subfloor itself is warped or water-damaged. In those cases, shimming the exterior base fixes the symptom without addressing the structural cause.
A good rule of thumb: if the toilet rocked for more than a few months before you noticed it, the wax ring has likely been compromised and should be replaced as part of any leveling repair. A new wax ring costs very little and the time to install it is already spent once the toilet is off the floor.
This is the correct approach for cases involving a failed wax ring, damaged flange, or uneven subfloor.
Tools and materials needed: adjustable wrench, hacksaw (if bolts are corroded), putty knife, wax ring, closet bolts, flange repair kit (if needed), spirit level, shims, silicone caulk, bucket and rags.
The single most common mistake plumbers see in DIY toilet resets is a homeowner pressing too hard on the toilet while lowering it onto the wax ring, causing the ring to shift sideways. Lower the toilet slowly and evenly. Once the base touches the floor, sit on it for 30 to 60 seconds to compress the wax ring correctly. The weight of a person is designed to seat it properly. Do not stand on it or press down on the rim with tools.
Yes, in two specific ways. First, a toilet that has rocked enough to break the wax ring seal loses siphon efficiency because air is drawn in around a compromised seal rather than through the trap during the flush cycle. Second, if the toilet bowl itself is significantly out of level, the water level inside the bowl sits lower on one side, which reduces the siphon head needed for a complete flush.
In practice, most homeowners notice this as a toilet that needs two flushes more often than it used to. Brands with high MaP flush scores, such as the TOTO Drake (G-Max siphon, rated at 1000 grams), the Kohler Cimarron, or the American Standard Champion 4, are more resilient to minor seal degradation than budget models, but no toilet flushes at its designed efficiency through a broken seal.
If you have been dealing with a toilet that seemed to lose flushing power gradually, check whether it has also started to rock slightly. The two problems often develop together. Owners of the best flushing toilets report that a properly sealed, correctly leveled installation restores flush performance to spec without any other adjustment.
| Shim Type | Material | Max Gap Fill | Moisture Resistant | Recommended |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plastic toilet shims | PVC / polypropylene | 3/8 inch | Yes | Yes |
| Composite shims | Recycled plastic | 1/2 inch | Yes | Yes |
| Metal shims | Stainless steel | 1/4 inch | Yes | Use with care |
| Wood shims | Cedar or pine | Any | No | Never |
| Rubber shims | EPDM rubber | 1/4 inch | Yes | Temporary only |
Any slope that causes the toilet to rock is enough to warrant shimming. Structurally, floors are built to a tolerance of 3/16 inch over 10 feet, per standard residential construction practice. Toilet bases are typically 14 to 18 inches wide, which means a floor out of tolerance can create a gap of 1/16 inch or more under one corner of the base. That is sufficient to allow micro-movement during use. The wax ring tolerates very little movement before it separates from either the flange or the toilet horn.
In bathrooms with large-format tile, the tiles themselves are often perfectly flat, but the grout lines between tiles fall fractionally below the tile surface, and a toilet base sitting across multiple grout lines will rock slightly. The fix in that situation is to shim the rocking corner to bridge the grout lines or to remove a very small amount of grout at the high point using a grout saw. Shimming is almost always faster and less risky to the tile.
Contractors working on bathroom tile remodels frequently find that a new tile floor causes an existing toilet to rock even when it previously sat flat. New tile adds height, but the toilet flange stays at its original height relative to the old floor. If the flange now sits below the finished tile surface, a standard wax ring may not seal properly without an extender ring, and the toilet will also need shimming to account for the new tile height variation. This is a very common scenario in bathroom renovation projects and is worth discussing with your tile contractor before the toilet is reinstalled.
No. Caulk is flexible and will compress under the weight of the toilet plus a seated person, meaning the toilet will sink to its lowest position regardless of how much caulk you apply. Caulk around the base is a sealant and cosmetic finish, not a structural support. Shims must carry the load. Caulk then seals around the shims to prevent moisture from getting under the toilet base and causing floor damage over time.
A related question comes up with grout. Some homeowners grout the toilet base to the tile floor. This is not recommended by any major toilet manufacturer, including TOTO, Kohler, American Standard, or Gerber. Grout is rigid and inflexible. A toilet that shifts at all, even microscopically during flushing, will crack grouted joints, which then allows water infiltration that is worse than the problem you were trying to solve.
A toilet that has been rocking for a significant period may need more than shims and a new wax ring. Check for these related issues while the toilet is accessible:
For a complete guide to this type of work, see our article on toilet leaking at the base and our wax ring replacement guide. If your toilet was already wobbling before you noticed the leveling issue, also review our notes on tightening a loose toilet.
Yes, in most cases. If the wax ring is still intact (no water staining, no sewer smell at the base), plastic shims can be slid under the low side of the base and the toilet bolts tightened without disturbing the seal. Only remove the toilet if the wax ring has failed or the subfloor is damaged.
Plastic or polypropylene toilet-specific shims are the best choice. They resist moisture, do not compress under load, and come pre-tapered for easy installation. Look for packs labeled "toilet shims" or "closet shims" at any plumbing supply or home improvement store. Avoid wood, which absorbs water and deteriorates under a toilet.
Toilet base nuts should be tightened to snug plus about a quarter to half turn with an adjustable wrench, alternating between the two bolts. The toilet should not shift or rock under firm hand pressure, but you should stop well before the nut is as tight as it will go. Overtightening cracks the mounting ears on the toilet base, which is an expensive mistake on porcelain.
A new toilet rocking immediately after installation almost always means the floor is uneven or the wax ring seated unevenly. Remove the toilet, inspect the wax ring for complete even compression, and check the floor for level before resetting. It is also worth confirming the closet bolts are positioned straight and parallel before lowering the toilet onto them.
Look for cracks in the flange ring, missing sections, or a flange that sits significantly below finished floor level. A damaged flange will allow the toilet to shift even when the bolts are tightened, because the bolt slots that hold the closet bolts are broken. A flange repair ring that bolts over the existing flange is a reliable fix for most crack patterns without requiring full drain access.
A very slight tilt of under 1/8 inch side to side is unlikely to cause functional problems if the toilet is firmly secured and the wax ring is sealed. A visible tilt or any amount of rocking is not acceptable and should be corrected. The wax ring depends on a stable, level joint to maintain its seal over years of use.
Yes, over time. A rocking toilet flexes the wax ring seal with every flush and every time someone sits down. This eventually breaks the seal, allowing wastewater to seep between the toilet base and the floor. In wood subfloor construction, that moisture causes rot that can spread under the tile or vinyl and require significant subfloor repair far beyond the toilet area.
Yes, but leave a small gap at the rear of the base. The gap allows water from a future wax ring failure to escape where it can be seen, rather than pooling unseen underneath the toilet for months. Caulking completely around the base with no gap traps water and delays discovery of a failing seal, making the floor damage far worse.
A wax ring that is correctly installed on a level, stable toilet can last the life of the toilet (20 to 30 years or more). Wax rings only fail prematurely when the toilet moves, when the flange is in poor condition, or when the installation was incorrect. If you are removing the toilet for any reason, always install a new wax ring because they do not reseal reliably once disturbed.
Yes. A broken wax ring seal allows sewer gas to pass around the base of the toilet into the bathroom. Hydrogen sulfide (the source of rotten egg smell) is the most common gas detected, but a full range of sewer gases can escape through a failed seal. If you smell sewer gas near a toilet, inspect the base for rocking and check whether the caulk bead has cracked or separated.
100 percent silicone caulk is the best choice for around a toilet base. It remains flexible after curing, adheres to both porcelain and tile, and resists the moisture of a bathroom environment far better than latex or acrylic caulk. White silicone matches most toilet colors. Sanded grout-colored caulk is available if your tile requires it.
Not inherently. Both one-piece and two-piece toilets require a flat floor and correct shimming. One-piece models from TOTO (UltraMax II, Aquia IV), Kohler, and Woodbridge (T-0001) tend to have a wider base footprint which can bridge small floor variations, but they still need shimming on any floor with more than minimal slope. Their heavier weight does make them less likely to shift once bolted down.
Rocking describes a toilet that pivots diagonally, with two opposite corners alternating between the floor and a raised position. Wobbling describes a toilet that shifts in any direction under pressure without a consistent pivot point. Rocking usually means uneven floor; wobbling usually means loose flange bolts or a damaged flange. Both need to be fixed, but the repair is different.
A thicker wax ring compensates for a flange that sits below floor level, but it does not substitute for shimming an unlevel toilet. If the toilet is not level, a thicker wax ring still compresses unevenly and will fail at the thin side over time. Use a flange extender ring to address flange height, and shims to address floor levelness. They solve different problems.
Call a licensed plumber if the subfloor is soft or shows signs of water damage, if the toilet flange is broken beyond what a repair ring can address, if the drain pipe itself appears misaligned or damaged, or if you find active water damage or mold growth under or around the toilet. These conditions require professional assessment to avoid compounding the damage.
The toilet must be level regardless of which direction the floor slopes. A toilet that tilts forward toward the bowl increases the risk of the water seal in the bowl sitting too low, which reduces flush siphon head. Backward tilt changes how tank water enters the bowl during flushing. Side-to-side tilt stresses one side of the wax ring more than the other. All directions of tilt should be corrected with shims.
Correctly installed plastic shims that are fully in contact with both the toilet base and the floor will not make noise. If a shim clicks or creaks, it is either not fully seated under the base or is carrying uneven load. Add a second shim alongside the first or reposition it until the contact is solid and the movement stops entirely.
A toilet significantly out of level may show reduced flush performance because the water level inside the bowl differs from the design spec, altering the siphon dynamics. More importantly, a rocking toilet that has broken its wax ring seal draws air into the siphon path during flushing, which reduces the vacuum needed to pull waste through the trap. This appears as a toilet that flushes weakly or incompletely even though nothing else has changed.
A toilet that is not level is a genuinely fixable problem and a repair worth prioritizing. Plastic shims under the low side of the base, evenly tightened bolts, and a fresh bead of silicone caulk solve the majority of cases without removing the toilet. When the wax ring has already failed, or the subfloor is soft, taking the extra step of pulling the toilet and addressing those conditions before reinstalling is the right call. The cost of a new wax ring, a set of shims, and a tube of caulk is far less than the cost of subfloor repair from a broken seal that went unfixed for a year. Any toilet, from a basic American Standard Cadet 3 to a high-efficiency TOTO Aquia IV or a Kohler Cimarron, performs at its designed flush rating only when it is correctly sealed and sitting flat.
How we rank & our data sources
We do not run physical lab tests. Rankings are built from published, verifiable data and real owner feedback, never paid placement.
Researched by Derek Whitman · Last updated March 26, 2026 · Our review method

Refined, softly curved one-piece and skirted silhouettes with a polished, Parisian-elegant profile, paired with verified MaP flush scores rather than a stylist's…
Read the guide
Clean, low-profile silhouettes with real MaP-verified flush performance and efficient dual-flush water use, sized for a minimalist Nordic bathroom without sacrificing function.
Read the guide
Classic two-piece toilets with tall tanks and elegant, understated proportions, the quiet country-house look that suits a traditional English bathroom without tipping…
Read the guide