White vs Colored Toilet: Which Holds Its Value?
ComparisonsA data-driven look at resale impact, long-term availability, and which color choice makes more sense for your bathroom and your budget.
Read the guideAn honest, spec-by-spec comparison of TOTO's two most popular gravity toilets, the original Drake and the Drake II, using published MaP flush-test scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush valve and trapway dimensions, gallons-per-flush ratings and aggregated owner reviews, so you can decide which Drake fits your bathroom, your cleaning habits and your budget.
Research updated June 2026.
For most buyers the TOTO Drake II is the better choice. It uses a 1.28-gallon flush, a 3-inch flush valve and a sleeker fully skirted base that hides the trapway and wipes clean in seconds. Choose the original Drake instead if you want the cheapest TOTO, a 1,000-gram MaP flush in 1.6-gallon trim, round-bowl options and an exposed trapway that is easy to service.
The TOTO Drake and the TOTO Drake II are the two toilets buyers cross-shop most often inside TOTO's lineup, and for good reason. They share a name, a flush philosophy and a reputation as some of the most reliable gravity toilets sold in North America. Both use TOTO's well-known siphon-jet flush, both are two-piece designs, and both have earned long-running loyalty from plumbers and homeowners who want a toilet that simply works for a decade or more. If you have narrowed your search to these two, you are not choosing between a strong toilet and a weak one. You are choosing between TOTO's value workhorse and its refined, more efficient, easier-to-clean successor.
The differences are real but specific. The original Drake is the older, lower-cost model, usually sold at 1.6 gallons per flush, with an exposed trapway you can see along the side of the bowl and a 3-inch flush valve on current SKUs. The Drake II is the modern redesign, built around a 1.28-gallon WaterSense flush, a fully concealed skirted trapway that gives the base a smooth, furniture-like look, and TOTO's CeFiONtect glaze as standard. That single design gap ripples into water use, cleaning, looks, price and flush feel. This guide compares the two head to head using published manufacturer specifications, MaP (Maximum Performance) flush-test gram scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush valve and trapway dimensions, bowl heights and shapes, and aggregated owner ratings. For the broadest cross-brand ranking of flush strength, the pillar guide to the best flushing toilets covers TOTO alongside Kohler, American Standard and the rest. This page stays focused on the choice between these two Drake models.
We do not test toilets in a lab. We compare manufacturer specifications, published MaP flush-test gram scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush-valve and trapway dimensions, gallons-per-flush ratings, bowl heights and shapes, rough-in dimensions and aggregated owner ratings across major retailers. Where one model clearly suits a use case better, we say so plainly rather than calling a single universal winner.
A side-by-side look at the two models in their common comfort-height, elongated, two-piece configurations. Higher MaP grams means more waste cleared per flush, and a lower GPF means less water used. The tinted cell shows which model tends to lead on that row. Exact figures vary slightly by SKU, so confirm the spec sheet for the specific model number you buy.
| Spec | TOTO Drake | TOTO Drake II |
|---|---|---|
| Full flush MaP score | 1,000 g | 800 g |
| Gallons per flush | 1.6 (and 1.28 on select SKUs) | 1.28 |
| Flush valve diameter | 3 in | 3 in |
| Trapway design | Exposed (visible) | Fully skirted (concealed) |
| CeFiONtect glaze | Available on some SKUs | Standard |
| WaterSense certified | Yes (1.28 SKUs) | Yes |
| Ease of cleaning the base | More nooks around trapway | Smooth, wipe-clean skirt |
| Bowl shape options | Round and elongated | Elongated (mainly) |
| Height options | Standard and Universal Height | Universal Height (comfort) |
| Relative price | Lower | Higher |
| Typical owner rating | 4.7 | 4.7 |
At the simplest level, the Drake II is what TOTO built when it modernized the original Drake. The classic Drake has been on the market for years as TOTO's no-nonsense value toilet: a two-piece gravity design with an exposed trapway, usually rated at 1.6 gallons per flush, and a price that undercuts most of the brand's other models. The Drake II keeps the same Drake DNA and the same dependable siphon-jet flush, then adds three meaningful upgrades. It drops the flush volume to 1.28 gallons for WaterSense certification, it hides the trapway behind a fully skirted base for a smooth furniture-like look, and it ships with TOTO's CeFiONtect ceramic glaze as standard to help waste rinse away and slow staining.
Those three changes are the whole story. Everything else about the two toilets is closely matched: both use a 3-inch flush valve on current SKUs, both are two-piece toilets, both are sold in Universal Height (comfort height) configurations, and both carry TOTO's strong reliability reputation and warranty. The honest framing is that the Drake II is the refined, more efficient, easier-to-clean version, and the Drake is the simpler, cheaper, easier-to-service original. Neither is a downgrade. They are tuned for different priorities, which is exactly why so many buyers cross-shop them.
Flushing power is measured most reliably by the independent MaP (Maximum Performance) test, which reports how many grams of solid waste a toilet clears in a single flush. The original Drake, in its 1.6-gallon form, has more water per flush and uses it to reach a 1,000-gram MaP score, the practical ceiling of the test and one of the strongest flushes you can buy at any price. That extra half-gallon of water gives the classic Drake a brute clearing margin that has made it a favorite of plumbers and landlords for years. Even in its 1.28-gallon SKUs the Drake remains a strong flusher, but the headline 1,000-gram figure belongs to the 1.6-gallon version.
The Drake II runs on 1.28 gallons and typically posts an 800-gram MaP score. That is comfortably above the 350-gram WaterSense minimum and well past what an average household produces in one flush, so the Drake II clears a normal load in a single push without complaint. TOTO engineered the Drake II's bowl and siphon jet specifically to make 1.28 gallons clear effectively, and it does. The gap between 1,000 and 800 grams is real, but it lives in the territory above what most homes ever demand. The honest takeaway is that you should choose the original 1.6-gallon Drake for maximum clearing margin and the Drake II for the best balance of strength and water savings.
The Drake name appears on both 1.6-gallon and 1.28-gallon SKUs, so the badge alone does not tell you the flush volume. If maximum power and a 1,000-gram MaP score matter most, buy the 1.6-gallon original Drake. If water savings and WaterSense rebates matter most, buy the 1.28-gallon Drake II or a 1.28-gallon Drake. Confirm the gallons-per-flush figure on the exact model number before you order.
Clog resistance comes down to two things working together: how forcefully water moves through the bowl, and how wide and smooth the trapway is for waste to pass. Both Drakes share TOTO's strong siphon-jet flush and a generously sized, computer-designed trapway, which is a big part of why TOTO toilets in general have such a low clog reputation. The original 1.6-gallon Drake gets an extra edge purely from water volume: more gallons per flush means more force to push a heavy load through, and its 1,000-gram MaP score reflects that. For a household that has fought recurring backups, the 1.6-gallon Drake is the safer bet.
The Drake II uses the same family of trapway engineering with TOTO's CeFiONtect glaze, which gives the ceramic an extra-smooth surface so waste rinses away rather than clinging. That glaze is a genuine clog-and-stain advantage in daily use, even if the 1.28-gallon flush has less raw water behind it than the 1.6-gallon Drake. In a normal home the Drake II clogs no more often than the original. The difference is margin on extreme loads, not basic competence. If clogs have never been a problem for you, either Drake handles ordinary household waste with ease. Our guide to the best toilet for frequent clogs ranks TOTO's siphon-jet Drakes among the top gravity options for exactly this reason.
Cleaning is where the Drake II earns much of its premium. Its defining visual feature is the fully skirted base, a smooth ceramic panel that runs from the bowl down to the floor and completely conceals the trapway. There are no exposed bends, no ridges along the side of the bowl and far fewer crevices to trap dust, hair and grime. You can wipe the entire base in a single pass, which is a real and recurring convenience that shows up every time you clean the bathroom. For anyone who values a tidy, low-maintenance toilet, the skirted Drake II is a clear step up.
The original Drake uses a traditional exposed trapway, the visible S-shaped curve along the side of the bowl. It is not hard to clean, but it has more contours to wipe around and more spots where dust collects, especially where the bowl meets the floor. The Drake II also ships with TOTO's CeFiONtect glaze as standard, an extra-smooth ceramic coating that helps waste and mineral deposits rinse away so the bowl stays cleaner between scrubs. The original Drake offers CeFiONtect on some SKUs but not all. If cleaning time and a sleek look are high on your list, the Drake II is the better choice. For more skirted options across brands, see our roundup of the best skirted toilets.
On pure value, the original Drake is usually the winner. It is one of TOTO's most affordable models, it tends to cost less than a comparable Drake II, and it still delivers TOTO's full reliability and a strong flush. For a rental, a guest bathroom, a basement bath or any situation where you want bulletproof TOTO performance without paying for the skirted base and the extra refinements, the classic Drake is hard to beat on dollars per flush. Its exposed trapway also makes some service tasks simpler, since nothing is hidden behind a skirt panel.
The Drake II costs more, and the premium buys you the 1.28-gallon WaterSense flush, the fully skirted easy-clean base and standard CeFiONtect glaze. For a primary bathroom, a remodel, or any buyer who cares about water bills, rebates, cleaning time and a modern furniture-like look, many feel the step up is worth it. The water savings alone, 1.28 gallons versus 1.6, add up over the life of the toilet and can qualify for local utility rebates that offset part of the higher purchase price. We never quote prices here because they shift constantly, so check the current price on Amazon for the exact model and configuration you are considering.
Most Drake and Drake II SKUs are built for a standard 12-inch rough-in, but TOTO offers 10-inch and 14-inch versions for older homes. Measure from the finished wall behind the toilet to the center of the bolt caps at the floor before ordering. Also confirm the bowl shape, since the original Drake comes in round and elongated while the Drake II is mainly sold elongated. This single pair of specs causes more returns than flush power ever will.
The MaP test was created to give buyers an objective, repeatable measure of flush strength instead of relying on marketing claims. It loads a toilet with a measured weight of test media and reports the maximum grams cleared in a single flush. WaterSense requires at least 350 grams to certify, which is the floor for an acceptable flush. In practice, anything from 600 grams upward handles a normal household with ease, 800 grams is genuinely strong, and 1,000 grams is the practical ceiling that the very best toilets reach. Higher numbers beyond 1,000 are not published because that is where the test tops out.
Against that scale, both Drakes are strong performers. The Drake II's roughly 800-gram score clears a heavy load with margin to spare on just 1.28 gallons, and the 1.6-gallon Drake's 1,000-gram score sits at the very top. The gap between them is real but lives in the territory above what most households produce in a single flush. The honest takeaway is that you should buy the 1.6-gallon Drake for maximum clearing margin and the Drake II for the best mix of strong flushing and water efficiency, not because the Drake II's 800 grams is somehow inadequate, because it is not.
If a buyer asks me to pick between these two without any other context, I lean toward the Drake II for a primary bathroom and the original Drake for a rental or a workhorse second bath. The skirted base and 1.28-gallon flush make the Drake II nicer to live with every day, and the water savings are real. But the original Drake is one of the best value toilets TOTO has ever made, and that 1,000-gram 1.6-gallon flush is genuine clog insurance. The moment someone tells me they fight clogs or want the cheapest reliable TOTO, I point them straight at the original Drake.
On water use, the Drake II has the clearer story. The entire Drake II line is built around a 1.28-gallon flush and carries EPA WaterSense certification, which is 20 percent below the old 1.6-gallon federal maximum. WaterSense requires a toilet to use 1.28 gallons or less while clearing at least a 350-gram MaP load, and the Drake II clears roughly 800 grams, far above that minimum, so it earns the efficiency without sacrificing flush strength. That makes the Drake II an easy pick when water savings or a utility rebate is a priority.
The original Drake is more of a mixed bag because it spans two eras. Its classic configuration is the 1.6-gallon version that posts the 1,000-gram MaP score, and that SKU is not WaterSense certified because it uses more water. TOTO also sells the Drake in 1.28-gallon WaterSense-certified versions, which qualify for rebates and use the same water as the Drake II. If water efficiency or a rebate is your goal, the Drake II is certified by default while the Drake requires you to choose a 1.28-gallon SKU. Always check the GPF figure and the WaterSense label on the exact model number before you buy. For the full list of certified options across all brands, see our roundup of the best EPA WaterSense certified toilets.
Both toilets are offered in TOTO's Universal Height configuration, which puts the seat at roughly chair height (around 16.5 to 17 inches to the seat). Universal Height bowls are easier to sit down on and stand up from, which is why they are the default recommendation for taller adults, older users and anyone with knee or hip concerns. The original Drake is also widely sold in a standard-height version, which sits lower and can suit households with young children, while the Drake II is primarily a Universal Height design. Because the original Drake offers both heights, it has a slight edge in configuration flexibility.
On bowl shape, the original Drake comes in both round-front (space-saving) and elongated (roomier) bowls, while the Drake II is mainly sold elongated. Both are designed for a standard 12-inch rough-in, with select SKUs available for 10-inch or 14-inch rough-ins in older homes. The clearest physical difference is the base. The Drake II's fully skirted body gives it a smooth, slim, furniture-like profile that many find more attractive in a modern bathroom, while the original Drake's exposed trapway has the traditional contoured look. If you are weighing a sleek concealed base, the Drake II wins; if you need a round bowl or a standard-height option, the original Drake is more flexible.
Neither Drake is the only TOTO worth knowing, and neither is your only option in its price range. Within TOTO, the Drake and Drake II sit in the value-to-mid tier, with the one-piece UltraMax II offering the same 1.28-gallon flush in a seamless single-piece body and models like the Vespin II and Aquia IV serving buyers who want skirted or dual-flush designs. If you are deciding between a two-piece Drake and a one-piece TOTO, our TOTO Drake vs UltraMax II comparison walks through that exact choice, since the UltraMax II shares the Drake II's flush engine in a one-piece shell.
If you are open to looking beyond TOTO entirely, the same money buys you strong Kohler and American Standard options. Our TOTO vs Kohler comparison weighs TOTO's siphon-jet flush and CeFiONtect glaze against Kohler's AquaPiston and Class Five systems, and the Kohler vs American Standard comparison covers two other major brands if you want to widen the field. The pattern across every brand is the same as it is here: decide how much flush margin, water savings and cleaning convenience you actually want, then pay for exactly that and no more. Brands like Woodbridge, Swiss Madison and Gerber also make capable gravity and skirted toilets worth a look if you want more options in the value and mid tiers.
The mistake I see most often with this pairing is a buyer assuming the Drake II must flush harder because it is the newer, pricier model, then being surprised that the older 1.6-gallon Drake actually posts the bigger MaP number. The Drake II is the better toilet to live with day to day thanks to its skirted base and water savings, but it does not out-flush a 1.6-gallon original Drake. Pick the Drake II for efficiency, looks and cleaning, and the original Drake for the cheapest reliable TOTO and the strongest flush. Both are TOTO-grade reliable, so you are not gambling either way.
The original Drake is the right pick when value and flush power sit at the top of your list. Choose the Drake if you want the most affordable reliable TOTO, since it undercuts the Drake II while delivering the same dependable siphon-jet flush. Choose it if you want the strongest flush, because its 1.6-gallon version reaches a 1,000-gram MaP score, the practical ceiling and the best clog insurance available. Choose it for a rental, a guest bath, a basement bathroom or any spot where you want bulletproof TOTO performance without paying for the skirted base, and where an exposed trapway makes service simpler. Choose it too if you need a round bowl or a standard-height option, both of which the Drake offers and the Drake II largely does not. Accept in return a visible trapway with more contours to clean and, in 1.6-gallon trim, higher water use.
Shop it here: check the current price on Amazon for the TOTO Drake.
The Drake II is the right pick when water savings, cleaning convenience and a modern look matter most. Choose the Drake II if you want a WaterSense-certified 1.28-gallon flush that cuts water use about 20 percent and can qualify for utility rebates. Choose it if you want the fully skirted base, which hides the trapway behind a smooth panel so you can wipe the entire base in one pass, plus standard CeFiONtect glaze that helps the bowl rinse cleaner between scrubs. Choose it for a primary bathroom, a remodel or any space where a sleek, furniture-like profile and low cleaning effort are priorities. The Drake II's roughly 800-gram MaP flush still clears a heavy normal load in one push, so you give up almost nothing in everyday performance. Accept in return a higher price and slightly less raw flush margin than the 1.6-gallon original Drake.
Shop it here: check the current price on Amazon for the TOTO Drake II.
Both toilets are dependable TOTO gravity designs that flush a normal load in one push and carry TOTO's strong reliability reputation. The Drake II is the refined, more efficient choice: a 1.28-gallon WaterSense flush, a fully skirted base that wipes clean in seconds and standard CeFiONtect glaze, all of which make it nicer to live with every day. The original Drake is the value and power pick: it costs less, its 1.6-gallon version posts a 1,000-gram MaP score that is the strongest flush in this matchup, and its exposed trapway is simple to service. If you care about water savings, cleaning and looks, choose the Drake II. If you want the cheapest reliable TOTO or maximum flush margin, choose the original Drake. Neither choice is a mistake. Match the model to your priorities, confirm your rough-in and bowl shape, then check the current price on Amazon for the exact configuration before you buy.
Ready to shop? Check the current price on Amazon for the refined TOTO Drake II or the value-focused TOTO Drake.
The Drake II uses less water and looks cleaner. It flushes 1.28 gallons through a fully skirted, concealed trapway with TOTO's CeFiONtect glaze as standard, while the original Drake is usually a 1.6-gallon toilet with a visible exposed trapway at a lower price. Both share the Drake name and TOTO's reliable siphon-jet gravity flush, so the difference is about efficiency, cleaning and looks rather than basic flush performance.
The original 1.6-gallon Drake flushes harder on paper. With more water per flush it reaches a 1,000-gram MaP flush-test score, the practical ceiling, while the 1.28-gallon Drake II typically posts around 800 grams. Both clear an ordinary household load in a single flush, so the Drake II is far from weak, but if you want the most clearing power the 1.6-gallon Drake has the edge.
It depends on your priorities. The Drake II's premium buys a 1.28-gallon WaterSense flush, a fully skirted easy-clean base and standard CeFiONtect glaze, which is real refinement and water savings. For a primary bathroom or a remodel many feel it is worth it. For a rental, guest bath or a buyer who wants the cheapest reliable TOTO, the original Drake delivers TOTO quality for less. Check the current price on Amazon for both, since pricing shifts constantly.
The Drake II. Its fully skirted base hides the trapway behind a smooth panel, so there are no bends and nooks along the side of the bowl and you can wipe the whole base in one pass. Its standard CeFiONtect glaze also helps the bowl rinse cleaner between scrubs. The original Drake's exposed trapway has more contours to clean around, especially where the bowl meets the floor.
The Drake II uses 1.28 gallons per flush across its line and is EPA WaterSense certified. The original Drake is most commonly a 1.6-gallon toilet, though TOTO also sells it in 1.28-gallon WaterSense SKUs. The 1.28-gallon flush uses about 20 percent less water than a 1.6-gallon model, which adds up over the life of the toilet and can qualify for local utility rebates.
The Drake II is WaterSense certified at 1.28 gallons across its line. The original Drake is sold in both an older 1.6-gallon version that is not certified and 1.28-gallon SKUs that are certified, so it can qualify if you choose the right model. If water efficiency or a rebate matters, the Drake II is certified by default, while the Drake requires you to confirm a 1.28-gallon WaterSense SKU.
CeFiONtect is TOTO's extra-smooth ceramic glaze that helps waste and mineral deposits rinse away rather than clinging, so the bowl stays cleaner between scrubs. The Drake II ships with CeFiONtect as standard. The original Drake offers it on some SKUs but not all, so check the spec sheet for the specific model if a low-maintenance bowl surface is important to you.
The original 1.6-gallon Drake has a slight edge because its extra water and 1,000-gram MaP flush push heavy loads through with more force. Both Drakes use TOTO's strong siphon jet and a wide, computer-designed trapway, so both resist clogs well in normal use. For a home with a real clog history the 1.6-gallon Drake gives the most insurance, while the Drake II's smooth CeFiONtect glaze helps in daily use.
Yes. Both are offered in TOTO's Universal Height configuration, which puts the seat near chair height for easier sitting and standing. The original Drake is also sold in a standard-height version, which sits lower and can suit households with young children, while the Drake II is primarily Universal Height. Pick the height that suits the people using the bathroom.
Yes. The original Drake is offered in both round-front and elongated bowls, which makes it the more flexible choice for tight bathrooms where a round bowl saves a couple of inches of projection. The Drake II is mainly sold as an elongated bowl. If you specifically need a round bowl, the original Drake is the model to look at.
The Drake II. Its fully skirted base gives it a smooth, slim, furniture-like profile with no visible trapway, which many find more attractive in a modern bathroom. The original Drake has the traditional contoured look with an exposed trapway along the side of the bowl. If a sleek concealed base matters to you, the Drake II is the better pick.
Yes. Both Drakes use TOTO's widely available flush valves, fill valves and flappers, and TOTO parts are stocked at major plumbing suppliers and online. The original Drake's exposed trapway can make some service tasks slightly simpler since nothing is hidden behind a skirt panel, but both toilets are easy to maintain over a long service life.
For most rentals the original Drake wins on value, since it is the cheaper reliable TOTO and its exposed trapway is simple to service. Its 1.6-gallon version also gives strong clog insurance for high-turnover units. The Drake II suits a higher-end rental where the skirted easy-clean base and water savings add appeal, but for cost-focused landlords the original Drake is the practical pick.
Most Drake and Drake II SKUs are built for a standard 12-inch rough-in, the distance from the finished wall to the center of the floor drain. TOTO also offers 10-inch and 14-inch versions of the Drake for older homes. Measure from the finished wall to the center of the bolt caps before ordering, since this single spec causes more returns than flush power ever does.
The UltraMax II uses the same 1.28-gallon flush engine as the Drake II but in a one-piece body with no seam between tank and bowl, which is easier to clean but harder to handle and usually pricier. The Drakes are two-piece, which makes them lighter to carry and cheaper to ship. Our TOTO Drake vs UltraMax II comparison covers that two-piece versus one-piece choice in detail.
The Drakes compete with strong gravity models like the Kohler Cimarron and American Standard Champion 4. TOTO's siphon-jet flush and CeFiONtect glaze are its calling cards, while Kohler offers AquaPiston and American Standard offers very wide trapways on the Champion 4. Our TOTO vs Kohler and Kohler vs American Standard comparisons cover the cross-brand details if you want to widen your search.
Yes. The Drake II's roughly 800-gram MaP score clears a heavy normal load with margin to spare on just 1.28 gallons, which is well past what an average family produces in a single flush. The 1.6-gallon Drake has more headroom, but the Drake II is not a weak toilet. Unless your household has a real clog history or genuinely heavy use, the Drake II flushes plenty hard for family duty.
Both are backed by TOTO's residential warranty, which typically covers the ceramic body for a long term and the working mechanical parts for a shorter period. The exact terms can vary slightly by model and configuration, so check the warranty card for the specific SKU. Neither model has a meaningful warranty advantage over the other within the TOTO lineup.
If you cannot point to a specific reason, base the choice on your priority. Want water savings, easy cleaning and a modern skirted look? Buy the Drake II. Want the cheapest reliable TOTO, a round-bowl or standard-height option, or the strongest 1,000-gram flush for clog insurance? Buy the original Drake. Both are TOTO-grade reliable, so either choice gives you a toilet that should last for years.
The choice between the Drake and the Drake II comes down to what you value most. The Drake II is the refined modern successor: a 1.28-gallon WaterSense flush, a fully skirted base that wipes clean in seconds and standard CeFiONtect glaze, all of which make it the nicer toilet to live with day to day and the smarter pick for a primary bathroom or remodel. The original Drake is the value and power champion: it costs less, its 1.6-gallon version posts a 1,000-gram MaP score that is the strongest flush in this matchup, it offers round and standard-height options the Drake II largely lacks, and its exposed trapway is easy to service. For water savings, cleaning and looks, buy the Drake II. For the cheapest reliable TOTO or maximum clog insurance, buy the original Drake. Buy on your priority, confirm your rough-in and bowl shape, then check the current price on Amazon for the exact configuration before you buy.
A data-driven look at resale impact, long-term availability, and which color choice makes more sense for your bathroom and your budget.
Read the guideA complete breakdown of water consumption, flush performance, MaP test scores, EPA WaterSense certification, and real-world clog resistance -- so you can…
Read the guideWe compare the real-world cleaning difficulty of two-piece and one-piece toilets based on design, crevices, and maintenance.
Read the guide