TOTO Drake vs Kohler Highline: Which Flushes Better?
ComparisonsHome / Comparisons / TOTO Drake vs Kohler Highline Toilet Comparison TOTO Drake Two-Piece Toilet vs Kohler Highline Two-Piece Toilet: Which Should…
Read the guideA spec-driven, head-to-head comparison of standard gravity-fed flushing against TOTO's Tornado Flush, weighing published MaP flush-test gram scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush-valve and nozzle design, bowl-rinse coverage, noise, water per flush and aggregated owner reviews, so you can decide which flush system clears waste, resists clogs and keeps the bowl clean in your bathroom.
Research updated June 2026.
For the cleanest bowl and a quiet, powerful single push, choose TOTO's Tornado Flush, found on the UltraMax II and Aquia IV, which uses dual angled nozzles instead of rim holes for full 360-degree rinse coverage. Pick a standard gravity flush like the TOTO Drake or Kohler Cimarron when you want maximum clog margin from a wide-open valve at the lowest price. Both clear up to a 1,000 gram MaP load.
Gravity flush and Tornado Flush are not opposites in the way pressure-assist and gravity are. Tornado Flush is a refined kind of gravity flush. Both rely on the weight of water falling from the tank into the bowl to start a siphon that pulls waste down the drain, so neither needs electricity, a compressed-air vessel or a pump for the basic flush. The difference is in how the water is delivered into the bowl once the valve opens. A standard gravity toilet pushes water through a ring of small holes under the rim, while TOTO's Tornado Flush replaces those rim holes with two or three angled nozzles that fire water around the bowl in a spinning, centrifugal motion. That single change in water delivery is what separates a good everyday flush from one of the cleanest, quietest flushes in the residential category.
This guide compares the two flush approaches head to head using published manufacturer specifications, MaP (Maximum Performance) flush-test gram scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush-valve and nozzle design, bowl-rinse coverage, gallons-per-flush ratings, noise behavior and aggregated owner ratings. Standard gravity flushing is the dominant system across every brand, from the TOTO Drake and Kohler Cimarron to the American Standard Cadet 3, Woodbridge T-0001, Swiss Madison St. Tropez and Gerber Viper. Tornado Flush is TOTO's proprietary upgrade, fitted to models like the UltraMax II, Aquia IV, Vespin II and Entrada. For the broadest cross-brand ranking of flush strength, the pillar guide to the best flushing toilets ranks gravity and Tornado models together. This page stays focused on the choice between the two flush systems.
We do not test toilets in a lab. We compare manufacturer specifications, published MaP flush-test gram scores, EPA WaterSense listings, flush-valve diameters, nozzle and rim design, bowl-rinse coverage, gallons-per-flush ratings, glaze technology and aggregated owner ratings across major retailers. Where one flush system clearly suits a use case better, we say so plainly rather than declaring a single universal winner.
A side-by-side look at the two flush systems using a strong representative model of each: the TOTO Drake (a best-selling rim-fed gravity flush with a 3-inch valve) and the TOTO UltraMax II (a best-selling Tornado Flush with dual-nozzle delivery). Higher MaP grams means more waste cleared per flush. The tinted cell shows which system tends to lead on that row.
| Spec | Standard Gravity (e.g. TOTO Drake) | Tornado Flush (e.g. TOTO UltraMax II) |
|---|---|---|
| Full flush MaP score | 1,000 g | 1,000 g |
| GPF (water per flush) | 1.28 / 1.6 | 1.28 |
| Water delivery | Ring of small rim holes | 2 to 3 angled nozzles, no rim holes |
| Bowl-rinse coverage | Good, can leave streaks under rim | 360-degree centrifugal rinse |
| Flush valve | 3 inch (large, open) | 3 inch |
| Flush noise | Moderate gravity rush | Quieter swirling flush |
| Cleaning under the rim | Rim holes can harbor buildup | No rim holes to scrub |
| Glaze pairing | Often CeFiONtect on TOTO | CeFiONtect on most models |
| Brand availability | Every brand, every price | TOTO only |
| Typical price tier | Budget to premium | Mid to premium |
| WaterSense eligible | Yes | Yes |
| Typical owner rating | 4.6 | 4.7 |
The table makes the central point clearly: on the numbers that decide whether a toilet clears the bowl, these two systems are essentially tied. Both reach the maximum-tested 1,000 gram MaP flush, both carry EPA WaterSense, both run on a 3-inch flush valve and both can flush at 1.28 gallons. The differences are about how clean the bowl looks after the flush, how quiet it is, and how easy it stays to clean over the years. Tornado Flush wins on rinse coverage, noise and rim-free cleaning because it swirls water from angled nozzles instead of dribbling it through rim holes. Standard gravity wins on choice, price and universal availability because every brand builds it. The rest of this guide unpacks where each system earns its keep.
Tornado Flush is the right pick for buyers who want the cleanest possible bowl after every flush, a quieter swirling sound, and a rim with no holes to scrub.
This is Tornado Flush's signature strength. Instead of feeding water through a ring of small holes under the rim, TOTO drills two or three angled nozzles high on the bowl that fire water in a spinning, centrifugal pattern. That swirl reaches the full inner surface of the bowl, including the back and sides that rim-fed gravity toilets sometimes streak or miss. The practical result is a bowl that looks visibly cleaner after a single flush, with fewer skid marks left behind and less frequent scrubbing. Owners of the UltraMax II and Aquia IV consistently single out this rinse quality as the reason they would buy a Tornado model again. For a wider look at how TOTO's flush engineering compares to its biggest rival, the TOTO vs Kohler comparison covers it brand to brand.
Because Tornado Flush moves water in a controlled swirl rather than a hard vertical rush through rim holes, the flush sound is noticeably softer and lower-pitched than a typical gravity toilet. There is no sharp gurgle and no loud refill clatter on a well-installed unit. For bathrooms next to bedrooms, in open-plan homes, or in any space where a loud flush is a problem, the muted swirl of a Tornado Flush is a real quality-of-life upgrade. Pressure-assist toilets flush even harder but are loud, so Tornado Flush sits in a sweet spot of strong, clean and quiet at the same time.
Standard gravity toilets have a ring of rim holes that, over months and years, can collect mineral scale and bacteria that are awkward to reach and clean. Tornado Flush eliminates rim holes entirely, replacing them with the nozzle openings, which leaves a smooth rim that is far easier to wipe down and far less prone to hidden buildup. Pair that with TOTO's CeFiONtect ion-barrier glaze, which most Tornado models carry, and you get one of the lowest-maintenance bowls available. For households that hate scrubbing or want the most hygienic everyday toilet, this rim-free design is a genuine advantage gravity rim-fed toilets cannot match.
Two toilets can post the same 1,000 gram MaP score yet leave the bowl looking very different. The MaP test measures how much solid waste leaves in one flush, not how clean the visible bowl surface is afterward. Tornado Flush's edge is in that second, unmeasured quality: the swirling nozzles rinse the whole bowl surface, so if a spotless-looking bowl matters to you, judge by water delivery and rinse coverage, not by gram score alone.

A one-piece gravity toilet that uses TOTO's dual-nozzle Tornado Flush and CeFiONtect glaze to clear a 1,000 gram MaP load at 1.28 gallons while rinsing the entire bowl surface in one quiet swirl.
The UltraMax II pairs the Tornado Flush nozzles with a one-piece skirted body, so there is no gap between tank and bowl and no rim holes, which makes it one of the easiest toilets to keep clean. The CeFiONtect glaze adds an ultra-smooth ion barrier that resists waste and mineral adhesion, reinforcing the swirling rinse.
Aggregated owner reviews repeatedly praise the clean bowl and the quiet, decisive flush, while noting the one-piece design is heavy to move during install. The 1,000 gram MaP score puts it at the top of the flush-power range, so cleanliness comes with no compromise on waste clearing.
If a visibly clean bowl and a quiet flush are your top priorities and the budget allows, the UltraMax II is the model that delivers Tornado Flush in its most refined, low-maintenance form. It is the one we point most buyers to when they ask why TOTO flushes feel different.

A two-piece gravity toilet with a large 3-inch flush valve and TOTO's G-Max or Tornado-equipped variants that clears a 1,000 gram MaP load, the benchmark for a tough, affordable rim-fed flush.
The Drake is the gravity benchmark for a reason. Its wide 3-inch flush valve dumps the tank fast for a forceful siphon, and the G-Max version clears the 1,000 gram MaP ceiling at a friendly price. Some current Drake configurations now ship with Tornado Flush, blurring the line, but the classic rim-fed Drake remains a top value.
Owner reviews consistently call the Drake a near-flawless flush that almost never clogs, with the main critique being the standard rim holes that need occasional scrubbing. For raw flush-per-dollar in a gravity toilet, few models match it. The TOTO Drake vs UltraMax II breakdown shows which TOTO to buy.
If you want TOTO flush reliability without paying for the one-piece body or every refinement, the standard Drake is the smartest value in gravity flushing. It clears as much as anything on the market and forgives older drains.

A skirted dual-flush toilet using TOTO's Dynamax Tornado Flush to pair full bowl-rinse coverage with a 0.8 or 1.28 gallon water-saving choice and CeFiONtect glaze.
The Aquia IV brings Tornado Flush to a dual-flush format, letting you choose a 0.8 gallon reduced flush for liquids and a 1.28 gallon full flush for solids. The Dynamax version of the swirl gives strong rinse coverage while keeping average water use among the lowest of any gravity-based toilet.
Owners value the water savings and the clean swirling rinse, while noting its 800 gram MaP score, though excellent, sits just below the 1,000 gram Drake and UltraMax II. For most households the difference is invisible in daily use. It earns EPA WaterSense certification comfortably.
If you want the cleanliness of Tornado Flush plus the lowest water bill, the Aquia IV is the pick. The dual-flush button pays back on a household's water use over the years without sacrificing the swirling rinse.
A standard rim-fed gravity flush is the right pick when you want elite flush power at the lowest price, the widest range of brands and styles, and a wide-open valve that forgives older drains.
Standard gravity flushing is built by every brand at every price tier, which means you can buy a model that clears a 1,000 gram MaP load for far less than a Tornado Flush toilet. The TOTO Drake, Kohler Cimarron, American Standard Cadet 3, Woodbridge T-0001 and Gerber Viper all reach top-tier flush numbers with a conventional rim-fed gravity design. If your goal is the most waste-clearing power per dollar, a strong gravity toilet is unbeatable, because you are not paying the premium for TOTO's proprietary nozzle engineering. The flush is just as capable of clearing the bowl in one push.
Because Tornado Flush is exclusive to TOTO, choosing it locks you into one brand's catalog, heights, shapes and looks. Standard gravity flushing is available from TOTO, Kohler, American Standard, Woodbridge, Swiss Madison and Gerber, in round and elongated bowls, standard and comfort heights, one-piece and two-piece, exposed and skirted trapways, and every color a brand offers. If you want a specific style, a wall-hung look, a budget round bowl or a particular brand's design language, gravity flush gives you the entire market to shop. That breadth of choice is its own real advantage.
The best gravity toilets pair a large 3-inch or 4-inch flush valve with a wide glazed trapway, which produces a fast, forceful siphon that shrugs off the partial clogs common in older homes with long or low-slope drain lines. The American Standard Champion 4's 4-inch valve and the TOTO Drake's 3-inch valve are the classic examples. Tornado Flush models also clear 1,000 grams, but the broad gravity category includes the largest-valve toilets ever built for the worst-case clog margin. For problem drains, a big-valve gravity flush is often the safest bet of all.
Tornado Flush and standard gravity both flush hard enough that flush power is rarely the deciding factor. Decide what you actually care about first. If it is a spotless, quiet, low-scrub bowl, lean Tornado Flush. If it is the lowest price, the widest style choice or maximum clog margin from a big valve, lean standard gravity. Let that priority pick the system, then choose the specific model on bowl shape, height and rough-in.
The short, direct answers to the comparisons people search for most.
The two-system choice does not exist in a vacuum.
Standard gravity flushing is the foundation of the entire market, built by TOTO, Kohler, American Standard, Woodbridge, Swiss Madison and Gerber, while Tornado Flush is TOTO's refinement of gravity for a cleaner, quieter rinse. Beyond these two sit pressure-assist toilets, which flush even harder and louder using compressed air, and double-cyclone flush, which is a related TOTO nozzle system. If you are cross-shopping the brands behind these flush systems, the Kohler vs American Standard comparison covers the two biggest mainstream gravity brands, and the American Standard Champion 4 vs Cadet 3 breakdown shows the difference between a 4-inch and a 3-inch gravity valve. Across all of these systems, the rule that decides satisfaction is the same: pick a model with a MaP score of 800 grams or higher, a 3-inch-or-larger flush valve or proven nozzle design, the bowl shape and height that suit your bathroom, and the right rough-in. Get those right and both gravity and Tornado Flush will serve you well for years.
Here is the buying-guide shortcut we would give a friend. If you want the cleanest, quietest bowl and the lowest scrubbing for years, buy the TOTO UltraMax II with Tornado Flush and stop reading. If you want elite flush power at the best price, buy the TOTO Drake or a strong gravity model from Kohler or American Standard. If your home fights clogs on older drains, buy the big-valve American Standard Champion 4. All clear the bowl in one push. The flush system is a refinement choice, not a power choice.
These are two versions of the same fundamental siphon flush, and for a typical household either will clear the bowl, sip water and last for years. Tornado Flush wins on bowl cleanliness, with its 360-degree swirling nozzle rinse, on quiet operation, and on rim-free, low-maintenance hygiene, especially paired with CeFiONtect glaze, which is why it earns its place on premium TOTO models like the UltraMax II and Aquia IV. Standard gravity flush wins on value, on the widest choice of brands and styles, and on the biggest-valve clog margin from models like the TOTO Drake and American Standard Champion 4. Both reach the maximum 1,000 gram MaP score at the top, both carry EPA WaterSense, and both rely on the same gravity siphon, so neither is weak. Decide your priority, cleanliness and quiet lean Tornado Flush, while value, choice and clog margin lean standard gravity, then choose the specific model that fits your rough-in, bowl shape and height, and check the current price on Amazon before you buy.
Choose Tornado Flush for the cleanest, quietest, lowest-maintenance bowl, starting with the TOTO UltraMax II or the water-saving Aquia IV. Choose a standard gravity flush for elite power at the best price and the widest style choice, starting with the TOTO Drake or the big-valve American Standard Champion 4 for problem drains. Both hit a 1,000 gram MaP flush and carry WaterSense, so let cleanliness, price and clog needs decide.
Yes. Tornado Flush is TOTO's refined version of a gravity flush. It still relies on water falling from the tank to start a siphon, but instead of feeding water through rim holes it uses two or three angled nozzles to create a swirling, centrifugal rinse. The core flush mechanism is gravity, not pressure or a pump.
They are tied at the top. The best gravity toilets and the best Tornado Flush toilets both clear the maximum 1,000 gram MaP load. Tornado Flush does not flush harder in terms of waste cleared, it flushes cleaner by rinsing the full bowl surface with its nozzle swirl.
It prevents clogs about as well, not dramatically better. Both systems use a strong 3-inch valve and a forceful siphon. The widest-valve gravity models, like the American Standard Champion 4 with a 4-inch valve, arguably have the most worst-case clog margin, since Tornado Flush models use a 3-inch valve.
Tornado Flush. Its angled nozzles fire water in a 360-degree swirl that rinses the entire bowl, and it has no rim holes to collect scale or bacteria. Standard rim-fed gravity can streak the bowl and harbor buildup in its rim holes, making Tornado Flush the lower-maintenance choice.
Generally yes. Because Tornado Flush moves water in a controlled swirl rather than a hard vertical rush through rim holes, the flush sound is softer and lower-pitched. It is one of the quieter flush systems, well below the loud snap of a pressure-assist toilet.
Only TOTO. Tornado Flush is a proprietary TOTO technology, found on models such as the UltraMax II, Aquia IV, Vespin II and Entrada. Every other brand, including Kohler, American Standard, Woodbridge, Swiss Madison and Gerber, uses standard rim-fed gravity flushing.
Yes. Both standard gravity and Tornado Flush models earn EPA WaterSense certification when they flush at 1.28 gallons or less while passing the flush-performance requirements. The TOTO Drake, UltraMax II and Aquia IV are all WaterSense listed, as are most strong gravity toilets.
Both clear a 1,000 gram MaP load, so the waste-clearing power is equal. The Drake is a value two-piece with a classic rim-fed gravity flush, while the UltraMax II is a premium one-piece with Tornado Flush for a cleaner, quieter rinse. Choose the UltraMax II for cleanliness or the Drake for value.
CeFiONtect is TOTO's ion-barrier glaze that makes the bowl surface ultra-smooth so waste and minerals do not adhere. It is a separate technology from Tornado Flush but the two are usually paired on TOTO models, combining a full swirling rinse with a slick surface for the cleanest possible bowl.
No. Tornado Flush models flush at 1.28 gallons or less, the same as efficient gravity toilets, and the dual-flush Aquia IV can go as low as 0.8 gallons on a reduced flush. The swirling delivery uses water more efficiently, not in greater volume.
Both are TOTO nozzle-based gravity systems. Double Cyclone uses two nozzles plus rim-feed for a swirling rinse, while Tornado Flush is the higher-end version using two or three angled nozzles and no rim holes for fuller 360-degree coverage. Tornado Flush appears on TOTO's premium models, Double Cyclone on mid-range ones.
Usually yes. Because every brand makes standard gravity toilets, the category spans budget to premium, so you can buy a 1,000 gram MaP gravity flush for less than a Tornado Flush toilet. Tornado Flush carries a premium for its proprietary nozzle design, refined rinse and quiet operation.
Tornado Flush. Its controlled swirl produces a softer, lower-pitched flush sound than a typical rim-fed gravity rush. For bathrooms next to bedrooms or in open-plan homes, Tornado Flush is the quieter choice, while pressure-assist toilets are the loudest of all.
No. Tornado Flush replaces the ring of rim holes with two or three nozzle openings, leaving a smooth rim with no holes to scrub or to harbor mineral and bacterial buildup. This rim-free design is one of the main cleaning advantages over standard rim-fed gravity toilets.
A well-designed gravity toilet with a strong siphon and a good glaze rinses the bowl well, but the visible-cleanliness edge still goes to Tornado Flush because of the full 360-degree swirl and the absence of rim holes. For most buyers a good gravity flush is clean enough, while Tornado Flush is the cleaner of the two.
A strong standard gravity toilet usually wins on value for rentals, since models like the TOTO Drake, Gerber Viper or American Standard Cadet 3 deliver top-tier MaP scores at a lower price. Tornado Flush is the better pick when the cleanest, lowest-maintenance bowl matters more than upfront cost.
Yes. Tornado Flush is still a gravity siphon and clears a 1,000 gram MaP load, so it works fine on standard drains. For very old or long, low-slope drain lines, the biggest-valve gravity models such as the American Standard Champion 4 with a 4-inch valve offer the most worst-case margin.
No. They install with the same standard 12-inch rough-in, water supply and wax ring as any gravity toilet. One-piece Tornado models like the UltraMax II are heavier to maneuver because the tank and bowl are a single unit, but the plumbing connections are identical.
For a remodel where you want the cleanest, quietest, most refined toilet and the budget allows, choose a Tornado Flush model like the UltraMax II. If you want elite flush power at the best price or a specific style from another brand, choose a strong standard gravity toilet. Both are excellent long-term choices.
Both last for many years, since the core flush is the same gravity siphon with simple, durable hardware. Longevity depends more on china quality, glaze and maintenance than on the flush system. TOTO builds both its gravity and Tornado Flush toilets to the same high reliability standard.
How we rank & our data sources
We do not run physical lab tests. Rankings are built from published, verifiable data and real owner feedback, never paid placement.
Researched by Marcus Bell · Last updated June 28, 2026 · Our review method
Home / Comparisons / TOTO Drake vs Kohler Highline Toilet Comparison TOTO Drake Two-Piece Toilet vs Kohler Highline Two-Piece Toilet: Which Should…
Read the guideHome / Comparisons / TOTO Drake vs TOTO Drake II Toilet Comparison TOTO Drake Two-Piece Toilet vs TOTO Drake II Two-Piece Toilet:…
Read the guideA data-driven look at resale impact, long-term availability, and which color choice makes more sense for your bathroom and your budget.
Read the guide